| 1967 Dick Bienefelt |
| 1968 |
| 1969 Anthony Quinn |
| 1970 Tom McKenna |
| 1971 Peter Best |
| 1972 Charles Baird |
| 1973 Phillip Lumb |
| 1974 Alex MacDonald |
| 1975 Tom McKenna |
| 1976 Peter Best |
| 1977 Barry Zschoke |
| 1978 Peter Best |
| 1979 Joe Udovicic |
| 1980 Alex MacDonald |
| 1981 Ray Parke |
| 1982 Ian Abley |
| 1983 Kevin Smith |
| 1984 Ian Abley |
| 1985 Anthony Rimmer |
| 1986 Tom McKenna |
| 1987 Michael Di Pietro |
| 1988 Liam Monagle |
| 1989 Peter Sawdon |
| 1990 Bob Smith |
| 1991 Wayne Boyd |
| 1992 Charlie McCaffrey |
| 1993 John ‘Snow’ Compagne |
| 1994 Fabio Pizzirani (Winter) – Anthony Guilbert (Summer) |
| 1995 David Meldrum Jnr |
| 1996 Anthony Guilbert |
| 1997 David Meldrum |
| 1998 Anthony Guilbert |
| 1999 Andrew Howe |
| 2000 Wayne Boyd |
| 2001 Chris McKenna |
| 2002 Stephen Singh |
| 2003 Chris McKenna |
| 2004 John ‘Snow’ Compagne |
| 2005 Simon Wilson |
| 2006 Simon Wilson |
| 2007 Kamil Douglas |
| 2008 Chris McKenna |
| 2009 Sean Howe / Nathan Gratton – Link to votes |
| 2010 Chris McKenna |
| 2011 Chris McKenna – Link to votes |
| 2012 Bradley Chilcott |
| 2013 Adam Gorrie (Victory League) – Jack Dance & Connor Lizotte (joint winners – Northern League) |
| 2014 Callum Moore (Victory League) |
| 2015 Beau Blizzard & Adam Gorrie (Joint winners – Victory League) |
| 2016 Joseph Zupo (NPL) – Connor Lizotte (Northern Championship) |
