1967 Dick Bienefelt
1968
1969 Anthony Quinn
1970 Tom McKenna
1971 Peter Best
1972 Charles Baird
1973 Phillip Lumb
1974 Alex MacDonald
1975 Tom McKenna
1976 Peter Best
1977 Barry Zschoke
1978 Peter Best
1979 Joe Udovicic
1980 Alex MacDonald
1981 Ray Parke
1982 Ian Abley
1983 Kevin Smith
1984 Ian Abley
1985 Anthony Rimmer
1986 Tom McKenna
1987 Michael Di Pietro
1988 Liam Monagle
1989 Peter Sawdon
1990 Bob Smith
1991 Wayne Boyd
1992 Charlie McCaffrey
1993 John ‘Snow’ Compagne
1994 Fabio Pizzirani (Winter) – Anthony Guilbert (Summer)
1995 David Meldrum Jnr
1996 Anthony Guilbert
1997 David Meldrum
1998 Anthony Guilbert
1999 Andrew Howe
2000 Wayne Boyd
2001 Chris McKenna
2002 Stephen Singh
2003 Chris McKenna
2004 John ‘Snow’ Compagne
2005 Simon Wilson
2006 Simon Wilson
2007 Kamil Douglas
2008 Chris McKenna
2009 Sean Howe / Nathan Gratton – Link to votes
2010 Chris McKenna
2011 Chris McKenna – Link to votes 
2012 Bradley Chilcott
2013 Adam Gorrie (Victory League) – Jack Dance & Connor Lizotte (joint winners – Northern League)
2014 Callum Moore (Victory League)
2015 Beau Blizzard & Adam Gorrie (Joint winners – Victory League)
2016 Joseph Zupo (NPL) – Connor Lizotte (Northern Championship)